S Corp Reasonable Salary for Physicians

Navigating the Financial Maze: The “S Corp Reasonable Salary for Physicians” Guide

Hey there, savvy physician! 🩺💡 So, you’ve dived into the world of S Corporations, aiming for that sweet spot between maximizing profits and minimizing taxes. But, there’s that looming question: What’s a ‘reasonable salary’ when you wear the physician hat in an S Corp? Deciphering the problem of the “S Corp Reasonable Salary for Physicians” might seem like diagnosing a rare disease at first, but don’t sweat it! Let’s journey together, step by step, and decode this financial puzzle, ensuring you’re on the right track and in the best fiscal shape possible. 

S Corp Reasonable Salary for Physicians

What Is a Reasonable Shareholder Salary?

A common question arises when a physician forms an S Corporation: how much should they pay themselves as a shareholder salary? The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) requires that shareholders of S Corporations who provide services to the corporation receive a “reasonable” compensation. This salary is subject to Medicare and Social Security taxes. Any remaining profit after paying the reasonable salary can be distributed as dividends, which are typically taxed at a lower rate and aren’t subject to self-employment taxes.


Determining a Reasonable Salary for S Corp Owners

For physicians, determining a reasonable salary can be more complex. The key is to consider what other physicians in similar roles and geographic locations are earning. Several factors come into play:

  • Specialty: A cardiologist may command a different salary than a general practitioner or pediatrician.
  • Experience: A physician with 20 years of experience would likely have a higher reasonable salary than someone fresh out of residency.
  • Location: A physician practicing in a bustling urban area like New York City may have a different salary expectation than one in a rural Midwestern town.

One approach to understanding the nuances of compensation in the medical profession is to delve into various physician compensation models.

Health Reimbursement Arrangements and S Corporations

An added layer of complexity for physicians operating under an S Corp structure is health reimbursement arrangements. If the S Corp provides health insurance, it must be included in the shareholder’s W-2. It becomes part of the overall compensation package and can affect the reasonable salary calculation.

Comparing Salaries: United States Landscape

In the United States, physicians’ salaries can vary widely. It’s essential to consult local and national salary surveys, understand the median salaries for your specialty, and adjust based on your unique factors like years of experience, patient volume, and additional responsibilities. Websites such as the Bureau of Labor Statistics can provide insights, as can medical associations related to your specialty.


How to Determine Reasonable Compensation

  1. Benchmarking: Compare your compensation to industry standards.
  2. Document Everything: Maintain a record of how you arrived at your salary, especially if it’s lower than industry norms. It can be particularly important when venturing into areas like how to negotiate physician employment contracts.
  3. Reevaluate Periodically: As your role, responsibilities, and the medical field evolve, so should your compensation.

Conclusion: Balancing Fair Compensation and Tax Benefits

Balancing a reasonable shareholder salary with the desire for tax benefits can be challenging for physicians operating under an S Corporation. Regular reviews, consulting with peers, and staying updated on industry salary trends will ensure that your S Corp remains compliant and optimally structured for financial success.

Benefits of an S Corp Structure for Physicians

Overview of S Corporation Structure

An S Corporation, commonly referred to as an S Corp, is a type of corporation that meets specific Internal Revenue Service (IRS) tax criteria. At its core, the S Corp structure combines the liability protection of a corporation with the tax benefits of a sole proprietorship or partnership.

Key Advantages for Physicians

1. Tax Savings

One of the most touted benefits of an S Corp for physicians is the potential tax savings. With this structure, only the wages or “reasonable salary” paid to the physician are subject to self-employment taxes (Social Security and Medicare). Profits distributed as dividends are not subject to these taxes, potentially leading to significant savings.

2. Personal Asset Protection

Like C Corporations, S Corps provides their owners with limited liability protection. This means that a physician’s assets, such as their home or personal savings, are typically shielded from corporate liabilities in the event of any legal claims or business debts.

3. Flexibility in Profit Distribution

S Corps offers flexibility in how profits are distributed to owners. It can be beneficial for physicians who might want to allocate income in a way that minimizes tax liabilities, provided that they still adhere to the “reasonable compensation” regulations set by the IRS.


4. Credibility Boost

Operating as an S Corp can add a level of professionalism and credibility to a physician’s practice. It can signal to patients, suppliers, and other stakeholders that the physician is committed to the long-term success and stability of their practice. Organizations like The American Medical Association (AMA) often provide resources and guidelines to support physicians in their practice endeavors.

Considerations in Choosing the S Corp Structure

While the benefits are considerable, physicians should also be aware of the responsibilities and complexities associated with maintaining an S Corp, such as:

  • Paperwork: There’s a requirement for regular filing and strict record-keeping.
  • Salary Requirements: As previously discussed, the IRS mandates that physicians must pay themselves a “reasonable salary,” which can sometimes be a gray area and a point of contention with the IRS.
  • Limit on Shareholders: An S Corp can have up to 100 shareholders, which might be limiting for larger practices or those considering bringing in numerous partners.

In Conclusion

The decision to structure a medical practice as an S Corp should not be taken lightly. While the potential tax savings and liability protections are undoubtedly appealing, it requires a commitment to rigorous financial and legal compliance. However, for many physicians, the benefits of operating as an S Corp far outweigh the challenges, making it a popular choice in medical practice structures.

Pros and Cons of S Corporations in Medical Practice


In the dynamic landscape of medical practice management, the structure and framework chosen can play a pivotal role in a physician’s financial success and risk management. The S Corporation (or S Corp) is a popular choice among the various business models. Let’s delve into its pros and cons to help physicians determine if it’s the right fit for their practice.


Pros of S Corporations in Medical Practice

1. Tax Flexibility

Perhaps the most prominent benefit is that S Corps allows earnings and losses to flow through the owner’s tax returns. This “pass-through” taxation can result in significant tax savings, especially as only wages or salaries are subject to self-employment taxes.

2. Liability Protection

Under an S Corp structure, physicians are generally shielded from business debts or lawsuits. This means personal assets, like a home or car, are typically safe from practice-related liabilities.

3. Elevated Professionalism

Operating under an S Corp can boost the practice’s credibility. The distinction of being an incorporated entity can instill greater confidence in patients and partners.

4. Profit and Loss Allocation

Owners of an S Corp have the flexibility to allocate profits and losses in a way that may not strictly align with their percentage ownership. It allows for more nuanced financial planning and tax strategy.

Cons of S Corporations in Medical Practice

1. Administrative Burden

Maintaining an S Corp involves a lot of paperwork, annual filings, and record-keeping. This administrative overhead can sometimes be burdensome for busy medical practitioners.

2. Reasonable Compensation Requirement

S Corp owners must pay themselves a “reasonable salary,” which can be a complex determination. The IRS keeps a close eye on this, ensuring owners aren’t skirting payroll taxes by underpaying themselves.

3. Shareholder Limitations

An S Corp is limited to 100 shareholders. Also, shareholders must be U.S. citizens or resident aliens, restricting potential investors or partners for the practice.

4. Potential State-Level Taxes

While the federal tax benefits are clear, some states may tax S Corps differently. Understanding the local state tax implications is essential, which might not always be favorable.


Wrapping It Up

While S Corporations offer a blend of liability protection and tax benefits, they come with their share of administrative and regulatory challenges. Physicians considering this structure should weigh the pros and cons, ideally in consultation with financial and legal advisors, to determine the best path forward.

About Us: 

We are committed experts in the field of Physician Contract Review, proudly serving the medical community through our platform at Physician Contract Review. With a profound understanding of the healthcare industry’s complexities, we provide comprehensive contract review services tailored to meet the unique needs of physicians. Our team of experienced legal professionals is dedicated to ensuring that every aspect of your contract is clear, fair, and beneficial to your career. To learn more about our services or to book a review, please contact us today.

Scroll to Top